Tuesday 25 December 2018

Chullin 28: Bird Sacrifice - Ritual Impurity, Surgical Knowledge & Culminating Mental Helath Problems

Today's daf continues yesterday's discussion regarding the slaughter of birds.  The rabbis agree that these sacrifices require precision and knowledge, both of halacha and of bird anatomy.  The conversation includes blood, surgical procedure, and comparisons with other halachic rituals.  One of the concerns about blood is that a bird might bleed in specific ways that render it ritually impure for sacrifice.  

The detail in which our rabbis describe both the ritual and the halacha behind the ritual is sometimes difficult to grasp.  Why must we turn the bird's neck inside out to check how much of the siminim have been severed?  Why not just believe that we have done a "good enough job"?  

These thought patterns suggest interesting possibilities about being Jewish.  We have a long-standing, solid history of checking small details, repeating patterns, following rules through understanding those rules most completely.  Jewish achievement today includes that same comfort with repetition, research, practice, and argument.  Then again, these though patterns also suggest the development of mental health problems - anxiety, OCD, depression, etc.  

No comments:

Post a Comment