Discussing the Mishna shared at the end of daf 12(b), the Gemara wonders why it was necessary to state that having a boy was different from having a child. Doesn't any child - whether a boy, a girl, an androginos, or a tumtum raise one's place in the world? The rabbis speak about this briefly. It is clear that a boy is the 'ideal' child in Talmudic times, but all children were valued. There is one note that teaches us that some rabbis might not value girls - and thus even more so babies whose legal status was unclear.
The Gemara turns to the question of a wife who miscarries after her husband vowed to become a nazir if he has a child. What if the husband separated an offering, readying himself for nazirut, and then his wife miscarried? Is the offering now consecrated, forcing the husband to become a nazirite? But if there is uncertainty regarding nazirut, the rabbis are lenient. That means that he should not have to keep his vow - but what of the potentially consecrated animals?
And what if a friend heard this husband's vow and said, "and I"? Once any person says, "I am a nazirite" and then adds a conditional or a clarifying statement, that person is a nazirite. Perhaps the friend intended to become a nazirite when s/he her/himself had a child. Or perhaps the friend intended to demonstrate that s/he will love that baby just as much as the baby's father loves the baby. Should that person be held to his/her vow?
We end with a new Mishna followed by limited commentary. The Mishna wonders what should be done if a person vows to observe two terms of nazirut and those terms overlap. For example, he vows to begin a term of nazirut in twenty days and he also vows to be a nazirite now for one hundred days. The Gemara wonders: do we interrupt one term to serve the other term? When should that person be permitted to cut his hair? A fuller discussion will follow in tomorrow's daf.
I began Daf Yomi (Koren translation) in August of 2012 with the help of an online group that is now defunct. This blog is intended to help me structure and focus my thoughts as I grapple with the text. I am happy to connect with others who are interested in the social and halachic implications of our oral tradition. Respectful input is welcome.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment