- Gentile's oil may be forbidden because it is held in ritually impure vessels
- Oil may absorb the impure tastes from ritually impure vessels
- Rabbi Yehuda HaNasi (Rebbi) permitted this oil
- How could one beit din overrule another?
- Perhaps the ruling was meant to apply only to himself in one circumstance
- Perhaps this argument of which Gentile products were permitted/forbidden was among the great arguments of Beit Hillel and Beit Shammai
- Torah law forbids seclusion with Gentile women of the seven Gentile nations; they are considered ritually impure at all ages
- David's Beit Din forbade seclusion with unmarried Gentile women
- Beit Hillel and Beit Shammai forbade seclusion with any Gentile woman
- Decrees regarding seclusion followed Amnon's rape of Tamar
- Gentile boys are considered to be ritually impure as well and thus Jewish boys should not play with them
- The text hints that Jewish boys could be turned toward homosexuality if they spend time with Gentile boys who are ritually impure; zavim
- Gentile boys might be ritually impure from birth, from age 3 or from age 9
- Seduction might be possible at age 3 and intercourse could be possible from age 9
- Some rabbis note that girls would have to be much older than three years old to be seductive
- Regardless of when children might become capable of seductive behaviour or having sexual relations, decrees against Jewish and Gentile children intermingling were thought to be stringent and wise
- How could one Beit Din overrule another?
- A ruling that cannot be met by the majority of a community should not be carried out
I began Daf Yomi (Koren translation) in August of 2012 with the help of an online group that is now defunct. This blog is intended to help me structure and focus my thoughts as I grapple with the text. I am happy to connect with others who are interested in the social and halachic implications of our oral tradition. Respectful input is welcome.
Tuesday, 20 February 2018
Avodah Zara 36: Oil, Jewish/Gentile Intermingling
A brief summary of today's daf:
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment