Monday, 12 August 2013

Pesachim 54a, b

Today I will share some ideas gleaned from the daf:

  • prayer over fire at the end of Shabbat, havdala, is recited because 
    • fire was created at the end of Shabbat
    • the fire has 'rested' over Shabbat and is now benefitting us
  • Because "There is nothing new under the sun" (Ecclesiastes 1:9), these ten miracles were created in heaven at twilight on erev Shabbat to be revealed later:
    • Miriam's well
    • manna
    • rainbow
    • writing
    • writing instrument
    • tablets (10 commandments)
    • Moses's grave
    • the cave where Moses and Elijah stood
    • Balaam's donkey's mouth
    • the earth opening to swallow the wicked (with Korah)
  • The rabbis list a number of items, like tongs, and debate whether they were designed in Heaven or whether man created the first prototype
  • Was the fire of Gehenna (hell?) created on the second day, the sixth day, or in the second week?
  • Perhaps Anah (and Aiah, sons of Zibeon), created the mule, as he too may have been the result of a prohibited relationship
  • perhaps other things were created at twilight on erev Shabbat, including:
    • Aaron's staff with almods and blossoms
    • demons
    • the garment of Adam, the first man (perhaps animals skins or perhaps made of light)
  • Seven matters are hidden from people:
    • the day of death
    • the day of redemption (of the Jewish people for our sins)
    • finding true justice in some disputes
    • what is in another's heart
    • how one will earn his/her profit
    • when the monarchy of David will be restored
    • when the wicked Roman monarchy will end
  • Fundamental to the existence of the world are these three thoughts of G-d:
    • corpses will rot
    • the deceased will be forgotten from the heat over time
    • grain will rot (thus we must sell rather than hoard our produce)
    • and perhaps: currency will allow us to make payments
A new mishna tells us
  • where people work on the 9th of Av, it is permitted to work
  • where people do not work onthe 9th of Av, it is forbidden to work
  • Torah scholars should do no work on the 9th of Av
  • Rabban Shimon ben Gamliel: people should conduct ourselves as Torah scholars and not work that day
The Gemara elaborates:
  • outside of Eretz Yisroel, we may not be called a community, and we are weaker
  • thus we don't follow the prohibitions on intimacy, wearing leather shoes, and studying Torah over the 9th of Av and for mourners
  • the 9th of Av and other communal fast days are different re: number of prayers, stringencies, bathing, etc.
Particularly interesting to me is the rabbi's conversation about what was created by G-d at the time of creation and what might have been created by human beings.  Did the rabbis all believe that the world was created by G-d in accordance with the particular creation myth in Genesis?  Or was it possible that they questioned the existence of a G-d who demonstrated intention, agency, etc.?  If they believed that the word of G-d was true and unquestionable, how might they explain the existence of any number of things?  Without attributing those creations to G-d, of course, created "in advance" but hidden from us until the time was right.

I wonder why I enjoy bumping these two ideas together - creationism and evolution in the Torah world.  Certainly I'm not the only one!

No comments:

Post a Comment